Do I need a Sleeping bag for Via Monastica?

[VNwalking]

I'm walking the Via Monastica (from Holland) in April. Do I need my sleeping bag, or can I get away with a silk liner?

Does anyone know from first-hand recent experence? I'm leaning towards the liner, but even if you only need a sleeping bag once or twice, when you need it you really need it.

 

[J Willhaus]

Can you use the slightly heavier liner? Not the silk one? We have one called Thermo-something or other from Sea to Summit. It is orange and has a reflective liner. IT still worked in the summer as well.

 

[VNwalking]

Can you use the slightly heavier liner? Not the silk one? We have one called Thermo-something or other from Sea to Summit. It is orange and has a reflective liner. IT still worked in the summer as well.

I have one or the other already, with no possibility of (or interest in) shopping for something new - and just need to choose which to carry.

We plan to stay with vrienden op de fiets and in monasteries, where it sounds like a sleeping bag won't be needed. But there are also a few pilgrim's accommodations, and these may be different. Hence the question for boots on the ground experience.

 

[Tincatinker]

I'm walking the Via Monastica (from Holland) in April. Do I need my sleeping bag, or can I get away with a silk liner?

Does anyone know from first-hand recent experence? I'm leaning towards the liner, but even if you only need a sleeping bag once or twice, when you need it you really need it.

Depending on your accommodation choices, as always, I would take that sleeping bag. April & even May can bite. Last years weather / temperature data here: https://www.holiday-weather.com/amsterdam/averages/april/

It may just be because i'm a wuss but I'll take a sleeping bag to the Sahara

 

[VNwalking]

It may just be because i'm a wuss but I'll take a sleeping bag to the Sahara

The Sahara can get cold at night! That sounds like wisdom not wuss-ness.

Likewise the Low Countries in April. But I'm just not sure of accommodation conditions.

 

[Lance Chambers]

What I have done in the past is to wear the clothes I will be using the next day rather than to carry a sleeping bag. It also means I can wake up, put my boots on and start walking.

 

[VeronicaF1]

What I have done in the past is to wear the clothes I will be using the next day rather than to carry a sleeping bag. It also means I can wake up, put my boots on and start walking.

Me too!

 

[Vince Rollason]

I'm walking the Via Monastica (from Holland) in April. Do I need my sleeping bag, or can I get away with a silk liner?

Does anyone know from first-hand recent experence? I'm leaning towards the liner, but even if you only need a sleeping bag once or twice, when you need it you really need it.

Hi
I have done 4 Caminos walking in April, May, June, July. September and October. I have only ever used a liner and have never had any problem. Hope this helps.
Buen Camino
Vince

 

[Peregrina 2013]

Enlightened Equipment out of Winona MN USA makes down and synthetic quilts and sleeping bags that are so feather like they and fit quite well in the bottom of your pack without having to roll them at all, I just stuff it in and am ready t go My 50˚F quilt (there are other temp. choices) has been perfect for all of my Caminos and will go with me in April.
Take a look if you'd like:

Ultralight Backpacking Gear & Outdoor Apparel | Enlightened Equipment

Between our full range of sleeping bags, quilts and sleeping pads, we make your choice easy for how to travel light while sleeping well outdoors.

enlightenedequipment.com

 

[VNwalking]

I have done 4 Caminos walking in April, May, June, July.

I have done 6 caminos in March, April, May, June, and July. But not in Holland and Belgium. Spain I know well. But it's not the same. So I'm looking only for feedback from people who have walked in Southern Holland and Belgium. Thanks anyway.

Take a look if you'd like:

Thanks, but as I said above, I have both a bag and liner with no possibility of (or interest in) shopping for something new - and just need to choose which to carry.

 

[Skiwhizz]

Doing the Primitivo 1st week in April and leaving the sleeping bag at home for the first time this time in favour of the silk liner, much lighter. As all private accommodations booked only, I feel the risk of the cold being unbearable is low. Will find out I guess.
As you say above you are not sure of the accommodations, then this to me is high risk, whether this is the Low Countries or anywhere else, and would make the personal decision to take the sleeping bag! Via Monastica is new to me, sounds interesting, good luck!

 

[Former member 49149]

I'm walking the Via Monastica (from Holland) in April. Do I need my sleeping bag, or can I get away with a silk liner?

Does anyone know from first-hand recent experence? I'm leaning towards the liner, but even if you only need a sleeping bag once or twice, when you need it you really need it.

I know you only want information from those familiar with the accommodation options you will meet. I don't qualify. However, you said: when you need it, you really need it. Listen to yourself!
On the Portugues in July or August 2013, we were forced to buy a sleeping bag (the shop only had one at our price!). We took turns at using it as a cover at night, and were we we glad of it! The silk liners were not sufficient. Given that you have one: no pide pan!
Buen Camino!

 

[SabsP]

Do take the sleepingbag with you! If not needed I will be more than happy to drive to your accomodation and keep it safe for you till after your Camino. Bit like carrying some of your stuff with me on the train when you were walking up to Salvatierra!

Afterall I'm not that far away when it comes to driving in our two relatively small countries.
And it would be a good excuse to have a coffee with you...

 

[OnHellas]

It sounds like starting out with both could be a good idea. If the sleeping bag is needed, happy days (well, nights actually) you stay warm and comfortable and wake refreshed and ready to walk another day.

On the other hand, if you get to a point where the bag isn’t any use you can always send it home and have just the silk liner to carry on with.

Of course, it does depend on how bulky and heavy your sleeping bag is. Don’t worry, I’m not going to suggest buying a new one as you’ve made it very clear that a pre Camino shopping trip is NOT your list of things to do…..;-))