• For 2024 Pilgrims: €50,- donation = 1 year with no ads on the forum + 90% off any 2024 Guide. More here.
    (Discount code sent to you by Private Message after your donation)

Search 69,459 Camino Questions

Red cross - Black cross

Rev Anthony

Tony Budell
Time of past OR future Camino
April 2020
Hello dear friends, I put this question to Ivar Rekve and he thinks it a good idea.
Once this terrible Coronavirus pandemic has passed, would it not be possible to have a scallop shell with a Black cross as well as the usual Red cross. This way we could buy one those with the Black cross and leave them at various place on our Comino, churches, hostels etc as a tribute to those who have died throughout the World. Your thoughts on this please. Tony Budell.
 
Join our full-service guided tour and let us convert you into a Pampered Pilgrim!
Hello dear friends, I put this question to Ivar Rekve and he thinks it a good idea.
Once this terrible Coronavirus pandemic has passed, would it not be possible to have a scallop shell with a Black cross as well as the usual Red cross. This way we could buy one those with the Black cross and leave them at various place on our Comino, churches, hostels etc as a tribute to those who have died throughout the World. Your thoughts on this please. Tony Budell.

First: I so appreciate your thinking outside of the box to think of ways each person can show support.

Personally, I wouldn't want one. Nor would I leave anything at locations without first seeking permission to do so. . . even at Cruz de Ferro, it requires a regular removal of all the stuff left there, including memoriams.

I also think that this would open the door (maybe it is already open, but I haven't seen examples) to other causes doing the same with all sorts of color variations. Like the colored ribbon thing.
 
St James' Way - Self-guided 4-7 day Walking Packages, Reading to Southampton, 110 kms
A wonderful sentiment, but I am afraid that the camino traffic has reached the extreme level where we all need to follow the Sierra Club(??) dictum. "Leave nothing but footprints, take nothing but photos"
The ad hoc memorials are less of a problem than trash, toilet paper, etc but..........................
 
I think a better idea would be to pick out the place that needs some help and just contribute to it. While leaving a shell would be symbolic, it doesn't help keep the hundreds, if not thousands, of small albergues, casa rurals, private homes, and small bars and businesses that kept us fed, happy, and housed during our Caminos. Many of the towns that are on the Camino seem to live or die based on the thousands of pilgrims that march through their location. I fear for them and hope that they will survive for the next round of travelers.
 
Get a spanish phone number with Airalo. eSim, so no physical SIM card. Easy to use app to add more funds if needed.
I remember back in 1987 when I was hired to develop and implement an AIDS/HIV prevention program for a public health district. Outside of the large metro areas, like San Francisco, meaningful strategies to deal with this issue were hit and miss, and mid-size and small sized public health jurisdictions were beginning to address the issue even prior to observable illness or AIDS diagnoses.

Part of my task was diverted in 1991 to also develop and implement a case management system to be consistent with State requirements for health districts receiving funding. We had had out first diagnosed case that year. Being a smaller population base, we, of course, never had the total numbers that Seattle saw. But the challenges were still there.

One program that I had started as a public information event in the community, was World AIDS Day in 1988. It was part of a national observance.

Red Ribbons began to be worn in 1991 as a sign of Remembrance and Support. I recall how I found volunteers to make Red Ribbons so that they could be worn as part of our World AIDS Day event.

Then in 1995 at the World AIDS Day event, which by then had grown is scope and size as more HIV affected individuals became part of the community, a disturbing thing happened to me.

As I scrambled to get the final issues sorted out for the WAD program, I had neglected to put on a Red Ribbon. As I was moving through the auditorium to grab some extra programs to hand out, someone I had never seen before stepped out in front of me and caused me to stop. I started to hi, and then move around him, but, in a loud voice started berating me for refusing to wear a Red Ribbon.

One of the HIV+ individuals that I case managed moved alongside and introduced that young man to me and who I was. Without apology, the young man scurried away.

That's when it hit me. . . what had started as a good thing, a symbol of support, had become to some, a Virtue Signal.

That is perhaps why I personally do not care for a Black Cross addition to scallop shells or badges or pins. I do not want to have people's support judged by whether the can be observed wearing a symbol. That may be an overblown concern. . . heck, it might very well be.

But just as someone who eats a favorite food while ill, and then later vomits and suddenly cannot stand that food any longer, the Red Ribbon has sorta soured me on symbols as support.
 
Good points Dave, wearing a symbol is not as useful a sign of support as perhaps a contribution where it is seen to be useful or helpful to a small service provider.
I am sure our hearts all want to help, and that energy gladdens my heart.
 
I feel the same way about daffodils. They were among my favourite flowers until my mother died of cancer. Now I blanche whenever I see or smell them.
 
Down bag (90/10 duvet) of 700 fills with 180 g (6.34 ounces) of filling. Mummy-shaped structure, ideal when you are looking for lightness with great heating performance.

€149,-
Good points Dave, wearing a symbol is not as useful a sign of support as perhaps a contribution where it is seen to be useful or helpful to a small service provider.
I am sure our hearts all want to help, and that energy gladdens my heart.

Thanks.

I do want to make sure that others are clear: I do not begrudge others wearing symbols of support, nor do I judge or assign motivations as to why. I just assume that the wearer cares for the cause being supported.
 
The Camino is an experience that reminds one daily of those who left their bodies due to illness on the trail. Or those who had passed due to heart failure. We honor them as we move along. Same thing with the current situation. The difference is we as a global community daily now grieve. We all share the pain & rejoice for those coming out the other side. I personally think we will carry our experience without a symbol of it. As we still are not thru it.
 
St James' Way - Self-guided 4-7 day Walking Packages, Reading to Southampton, 110 kms
The place you could feasibly leave a shell behind would be the little bar in Alberguería on the Sanabres.
I wouldn't count on it. Luis is quiet strict about what goes up on the walls and how it's done. Each group that enters the bar can buy one of his shells which he will later put on the wall according to his system (the shells are grouped by date). If someone in the group wants to write a message to an absent friend or something, it must go on the same shell.
 

Most read last week in this forum

Could I ask what may be naive question. This will be my 1st Camino and I will be mostly staying in alberques. Could you please explain the bathroom/shower etiquette to me? I have no idea what...
Do i need both these apps? I want to spend as little time my device as possible so if one app will do fine that’s my preference.
I was planning to document my journey through my blog (or Vlog, as I would probably take lots of videos). I was thinking of using my iPhone, and I ordered a foldable keyboard to facilitate typing...
I did the Norte in 2017. This set off a wild ride of changes in life - shifting many things. I am now at a new plateau and it feels like the right time to do Camino #2, this time the...
Hi to all, I'm looking for a really, really good place (an artist) to get a Tattoo in Santiago, it could be before Santiago but I presume in Santiago I will be ready to have my first one. The...
My daughter and I will be on the Portuguese on June and July starting in Lisbon. We will arrive in Porto about the 27th of June. We want to stay for three nights. Can we stay in an albergue for...

❓How to ask a question

How to post a new question on the Camino Forum.

Similar threads

Forum Rules

Forum Rules

Camino Updates on YouTube

Camino Conversations

Most downloaded Resources

This site is run by Ivar at

in Santiago de Compostela.
This site participates in the Amazon Affiliate program, designed to provide a means for Ivar to earn fees by linking to Amazon
Official Camino Passport (Credential) | 2024 Camino Guides
Back
Top