For 2024 Pilgrims: €50,- donation = 1 year with no ads on the forum + 90% off any 2024 Guide. More here. (Discount code sent to you by Private Message after your donation) |
---|
And some thoughts are better left unsaid! I suffer from a form of depression and have talked with my not so good Dr.s and as any Dr would say talking about the issues is the best therapy ,And i would have to agreeBeiramar:
If you are looking for opinions, this is the place. In regards to the Physical or fiscal aspects of the Camino.
In regards to Peregrino's sharing their personal struggles, (Physical, fiscal, addictions or other challenges), I am even comfortable with that. That is their choice.
I do not, in my opinion, believe this is a forum to search for answers to mental health challenges one might face. While there may be qualified responders in this forum to do so, I do not believe this is the place for that type of advice.
I agree with your statement. "The reason for Peregrination often is unhappiness with current living conditions and search for an inner change". Those and many other reasons are the motivation behind many Peregrino's walking the Camino. That said, someone with more severe challenges, "depression, panic attacks or other disorders" such as you mentioned might be better served with face to face professional help. Someone who is not only Professionally trained but also competant. Not everyone who is a Phsyciatrist/Phsycologist or other mental health practitioner is necessarily good at what they do.
I wish you well in the pursuit of your answers. While I do not believe this is the right forum, my opinion is just one of many here.
Ultreya,
Joe
"Doctor, the people in my family treat me like a dog."
"Well, let's talk about it, shall we. Please lie down on the couch."
"But I'm not allowed on the couch..."
My name is Tracy and I have a foot in my mouth.
The simple act of sharing along the Camino helps and there is a great deal of sharing therejpflavin: with respect I think you are no doubt unintentionally somewhat stigmatising and marginalising mental health issues by saying that "this is not the place to discuss them". I don't think that anyone was discussing mental health issues. I think some pilgrims were agreeing that such things as depression and panic attacks can be just as prevalent on the Camino as bedbugs and blisters, but that these things are "not spoken of" here. My own feeling is it is this type of thinking which causes those who do have a proclivity towards anxiety or depression to bottle it up. Why not discuss it here? This section is about "medical issues on the Camino": depression, anxiety are medical issues, caused by an imbalance in the brain's neurotransmitters. Correctable through medication and cognitive and behavioural therapy, or maybe just a walk in the fresh air! The idea that somehow they only happen to "emotionally unbalanced" people went out with the last century. Mental issues are just as physiological as physical ones are and therefore DO belong here in this very courageous thread.
The Camino will cause anyone to become introspective, that is one of its beauties, and if the pilgrim has come because they are at a crossroads in their life - and this is often the case - depression, doubt, fear, anxiety may surface. If they do in an atmosphere of common caring and sharing then ALL involved may benefit. We are talking about common aspects of mental health here (20% at least of the population will experience a majorclinical depression in their lifetime: 1 in 5), not something needing extensive medication or hospitalisation! In my experience, pilgrims are by and large VERY supportive of each other at such normal times as when the Camino becomes a bit too much. And it happens to all of us. The help a pilgrim can get simply by being loved and accepted along the Way is infinitely superior to that given by any "mental health professional": and I am one!
http://www.headstartcentres.org
Congratulations on your 5 years... I often find it odd that more people are not "out" about being in recovery on The Way...hello beiramar
mental health issues are not easily discussed by those that are not sufferers
so if i told you i was an addict and bipolar
this might make others feel uncomfortable
.
there seens to be an elevation to heroism of those with physical disabilities doing the camino
but people generally look the other way when mental illness is spoken of
i am proud of having tackled the camino with my mental challenges
i also celebrated 5 years sobriety on the walk
a fairly big private victory for me
.
so if you want to raise this discussion in a public forum, i'm up for it
if not, youre welcome to PM me
.
so - if you are stable in your meds
and if you feel confident in yourself
and if your psdoc gives the go ahead
.
if not, you run the risk of having a wobble at an unconvenient time
and where you might not have access to meds of psdoc help
and in a language where you need to be able to express what youre experiencing
.
i took backup meds
+ a full script from my psdoc
+ a translation of the script into Spanish
+ a copy of the script emailed to myself
,
i knew that excessive physical or emotional exertion could possibly trigger an episode
and i wanted to lessen the odds of that happening a long way from my support base
.
other than some basic precautions
i am just a regular pilgrim
trying to make good
and find my way back home
Puertos de Perdon...I get clinically depressed. I was that way when I last walked the Frances, and I found it a profoundly lonely time.
Much good came from the experience, but I know how harrowing it can be when your mental condition isolates and alienates you from the merry, sweet, mystical pilgrims around you -- they are having the time of their lives and are really connecting to one another. You are walking the same path, seeing their joy, but have a few feet of insulating numbness between you and them. Very sad.
People more profoundly depressed would find it intolerable.
You may NOT find peace or release or friendship or recovery out there. Do NOT go to the camino looking for any kind of healing, or you will be disappointed. Don´t expect anything from it.
The healing comes when you quit trying. Even then sometimes it doesn´t happen. Sometimes not for another few months, or years -- or in a form completely different from what you expect.
If you are really ill, think twice before taking on the camino. It is a really difficult undertaking even for people who are healthy. You are putting yourself into a strange and challenging environment, and you may not be able to handle it. The Camino is NOT for everyone, no matter what the jolly people say... and there is no shame in stopping if it gets too much for you.
That is why there are "puertos de perdon" all along the track for people who cannot continue. They show that the Lord still loves you and there still is grace for you, no matter how far you walk on whichever trail -- that God is a whole lot bigger than Santiago, and you don´t have to "achieve" anything to win his love. That there is special grace for his children who suffer this way.
What makes a pilgrim tick?
I already answered that very relevant and productive question, but perhaps there is still one more aspect of pilgrimage that could be discussed in this beautiful and very interesting (What makes a pilgrim tick?) and nicely seasoned thread because it might interest more pilgrims and professionals.
In my job as tourist information councelor a long time ago I met many pilgrims (to be) and read dozens of their reports. It often struck me -beside being very original and individual- also how similar they could be in a certain way or aspect...
Evenually I noticed that sometimes somewhere on the Camino pilgrims could 'break', 'fell out of their role or character' (is that good English?) of -in the best pilgrim's tradition- being modest, easy going and taking life as it comes and instead they would get angry, impatient, discontent and behaving un-pilgrim-like, mostly for a short time and afterwards regretting it very much...
Then it struck me that these events happened more or less on the same legs of the Walk. The question 'why' has never left me and untill now I didn't get any answers, so...
Anyone?
Hi Bill , you are so wright, I wish you well and a Buen Camino, Peter.I have suffered sever depression brought on by social anxiety for years. I am now down to 1/3 of my anti anxiety medications previously prescribed ... My secret, exercise. I now work out three times a week at a gym and currently am training for the walk. I would not be so cavalier as to think all depressions are the same nor would I suggest that walking the Camino is a cure: however, for me, the Camino is my reward and celebration of my healing.
Buen Camino
Bill
PS doctors and big pharmaceutical companies hate this
I know this post was in the "wayback machine" but thank you for your service.This is so very true and that's why it's important to find a psydoc that can relate:
As a Marine, I'm already convinced that there's nothing I can't do given the proper resources and authority; therein lies the problem. Who does a Marine, or any military person, go to when there's the possibility of stress related issues? What we find is that PostTraumaticStressDisorder is the most common issue, therefore the psydocs treating that are basically just wearing the uniform (Navy for Marines) all other services have their own medical branch.
What all psydocs can relate to is a basic understanding about stress, it's origins and usual treatment.
When I was flying there was a scale of stressful incidents with related points: Getting engaged/married/divorced 100 points. Buying a new house/boat/car 25 points. Getting a traffic ticket that morning 50 points. Having a fight with your significant other 25 points. Losing a loved one 100 points, etc. Any single incident, or combination that resulted in 100 points...you were grounded for that day and sent to speak with the psydoc as a way to vent, or upon relating the situation further treatment might be needed.
Day to day combat is a whole different ball of wax. It's said that combat is 95% boredom and 5% stark raving terror. Pretty accurate. The key is how well you're trained to accept those things that can add up during even the boring times: being away from loved ones for months at a time, not hearing from them on a regular basis, impending birth or the death of a close family member. All these add up.
Some of us, who worked in specific arenas where the normal 95 to 5 % is reversed, we had psydocs that initially came from a similar background and then became doctors. For example, the Medical Officer on my carrier had started his military career as a Marine officer and served in combat. He completed his obligation and returned to civilian life going to medical school and then returned to active duty. All my men were comfortable with him because he could relate. In another organization I was part of there was only one medical officer we could talk to; not only was he a prior Army Ranger, he had all the clearances needed to allow us to spill our guts without reservation.
This may be a whole different view of the main thread, but I believe it relates to Biermar's key insight.
One size psydoc doesn't fit all. For some of us the day to day can be a battlefield and we will all relate to it's stresses in different ways. Sometimes we can recognize the on coming threat to our mental well being and effectively deal with it. Sometimes more intervention is required, be it a support group, a trusted family member or the right psydoc.
Walking the camino in all it's guises: spiritual, religious, cheap vacation, etc. provides an opportunity to test our physical condition and inner/outer self. For some of us it's magic the Way it all works.
The hopeful end result is that we return to that stable, safe and nurturing place we internalize as Home!
A very interesting question. As a social worker in mental health / psychiatry I would say it will all depend on your stress level and self acceptance. If one' s situation, wether it is medical or psychological, is stable and with the help of decent medication. If one has a helpline , a person who you can call at certain times or a companion/ buddy who you can talk to en route ( and who is equipped to help out ) I would give it a go. Stable mental problems or like stable physical issues : structure and time to rest, maybe use more private accomodations than albergues..., structure also in eating habits, staying away from alcohol. For example a stable patient with a depression who has enough selfknowledge can walk the Camino like a diabetes patient who could walk the Way. With extra caution and helpline but yes it is possible. I would not recommend the Camino for those patients with florid psychoses or someone in the early stages of a major depression.
Structure , structure, taking one's time and having a lifeline, compagnon de route...And assessment of the specific stresslevels.
I get clinically depressed. I was that way when I last walked the Frances, and I found it a profoundly lonely time.
Much good came from the experience, but I know how harrowing it can be when your mental condition isolates and alienates you from the merry, sweet, mystical pilgrims around you -- they are having the time of their lives and are really connecting to one another. You are walking the same path, seeing their joy, but have a few feet of insulating numbness between you and them. Very sad.
Yes, there is nothing more lonely than being alone in a crowd of happy people.I get clinically depressed. I was that way when I last walked the Frances, and I found it a profoundly lonely time.
On my subsequent Caminos I haven't been so concerned about being part of a group. I enjoy the company of others, but it's okay if I'm alone. What I love about the Camino is that every morning when I set out on the trail it's a new day with new opportunities.The healing comes when you quit trying. Even then sometimes it doesn´t happen. Sometimes not for another few months, or years -- or in a form completely different from what you expect.
Absolutely! I think that if you are looking for the Camino to "fix" yourself, you will be very disappointed. That's why I think that it's so important to go with no expectations. Don't watch the YouTube videos or read the books. You will not have the same experience. You will have your own unique experience, and you should not let the experiences of others color your Camino.Yes, I think it’s important we don’t over-sell the Camino as a cure all.
Yes, there is nothing more lonely than being alone in a crowd of happy people.
I also tend to depression, though I am generally pretty happy on the Camino (fresh air and exercise are truly medicinal), but I remember one day on my first Camino - I had started with a small Camino "family," but after about a week it sort of dissolved as some had to take it slower due to the late summer heat, and others found groups that they were more simpático with. Although I was still walking with a couple from the original group that I really liked a lot, I was feeling like I was walking "their" Camino, and not my own. So I made the decision to walk a longer stage than they had planned, which meant that we were no longer in sync on the Camino. The first few days I found it hard to find others to connect with, and I became down as I saw other groups laughing and smiling together. Then, one night in Astorga I ended up sharing a meal with quite a few other pilgrims. I didn't really know them, but then I started thinking that if the "lonely me" saw the me that was dining with that group, "lonely me" would assume that I was fully a part of that group - in other words, looks can be very deceiving - in some way we are all alone.
On my subsequent Caminos I haven't been so concerned about being part of a group. I enjoy the company of others, but it's okay if I'm alone. What I love about the Camino is that every morning when I set out on the trail it's a new day with new opportunities.
Absolutely! I think that if you are looking for the Camino to "fix" yourself, you will be very disappointed. That's why I think that it's so important to go with no expectations. Don't watch the YouTube videos or read the books. You will not have the same experience. You will have your own unique experience, and you should let the experiences of others color your Camino.
Old, but nothing out of date about it.Old
way out of date going back to 10 years ago
delate
Old
way out of date going back to 10 years ago
delate
Hi Sean. You have walked the feet off yourself! Lucky you. I hope you will manage another camino or two this year. I am not from Ireland, as your avatar says you are. I can't find how to say I am from Scotland but live in Ireland though.Old
way out of date going back to 10 years ago
delate
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?