For 2024 Pilgrims: €50,- donation = 1 year with no ads on the forum + 90% off any 2024 Guide. More here. (Discount code sent to you by Private Message after your donation) |
---|
What kind of weight were you carrying on your shoulders back then?Interesting view.
My '1st life' was in the Military for 22 years. Many moons ago.
We used old style Bergens that put all the load on the shoulders and had no hip belt. Those came decades later. The chafing on the shoulders and lower back could get really bad.
I can feel the pain in my shoulders just thinking of it!
Whoever came up with hip belts deserves a medal
Won't be rushing to load up my shoulders, sorry.
View attachment 69236
Interesting view.
My '1st life' was in the Military for 22 years. Many moons ago.
We used old style Bergens that put all the load on the shoulders and had no hip belt. Those came decades later. The chafing on the shoulders and lower back could get really bad.
@Robo Is that photo the bergen you were issued? You must be older than your photo suggests. I thought we had lost the last of the WW1 veterans a few years back...
Edit: Just seen somewhere that the 42 Pattern Bergen was in use up until the Eighties. So I came pretty close to getting one myself. I am getting old too
I've always been a proponent of dividing the load of my pack between some ratio shoulders and hips, often changing the ratio throughout the day. We pack rather lightly with a base weight of about 11 pounds. On our last camino my wife had some problems with her hips and felt better carrying the entire weight of the pack on her shoulders. I didn't think much of this until I actually tried it myself. To my surprise my back felt markedly better with all of the weight on my shoulders. I probably hiked 70% of last summer this way.
Not sure why this is, but I do wonder if having a majority of the weight on my hips somehow inhibits some natural movements of the mid and lower back as it relates to the hips. There could very well be a weight limit on how much the shoulders can carry in this manner. We both carry frameless Osprey Talon 33s, hers S/M and min M/L that are sized for our torsos.
davebugg, would be interested in hearing your thoughts on this.
FYI I am a self professed gear head and worked at North Face and Feathered Friends many, many, many moons ago.
Give it a try YMMV.
He would have had plenty of opportunity to try them out before. Although he lived in Britain from the age of two he remained a French citizen and returned to France later for his mandatory military service.I read H. BELLOC's book THE PYRENEES some time ago. Printed 1909! He was quite a fan of French Army gear which at that time included backpack, chest pack and additions.
11 pounds is a reasonable load on the shoulder girdle. If stresses begin to fatigue the muscles and ligaments around the upper shoulders and neck, or impinge a bit on nerves, the option is still there to refasten and adjust a hipbelt and walk with it for a while.
It is true that a hipbelt, properly in place, will place weight on the hips in a manner that changes the way the lower body (lower back to hips) responds to movement while walking. Some folks may feel this far more than others. After all, a properly positioned and tensioned hipbelt will put some compressive tension on that area of the body.
With a hyperlight load at 10 or 11 pounds, what is happening is that the need for the hipbelt to carry the heavy load, the way that is beneficial, is absent. Yes, I will still wear a hipbelt, but if I don't, the 11 pounds of weight is bearable to a healthy shoulder girdle.
With the hipbelt having a reduced impact on weight distribution, the scale sort of tips more toward noticing how a hipbelt constricts, rather than focusing on the relief of heavy weight being redirected away from the shoulders. So all of the potential minor downsides of a hipbelt is much more apparent, and for some folks that will mean a larger focus on discomfort CAUSED by the hipbelt, instead of RELIEF that the hipbelt provides at high load levels.
I hope that makes sense
@Robo Is that photo the bergen you were issued? You must be older than your photo suggests. I thought we had lost the last of the WW1 veterans a few years back...
Edit: Just seen somewhere that the 42 Pattern Bergen was in use up until the Eighties. So I came pretty close to getting one myself. I am getting old too
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?