For 2024 Pilgrims: €50,- donation = 1 year with no ads on the forum + 90% off any 2024 Guide. More here. (Discount code sent to you by Private Message after your donation) |
---|
Buen CaminoHi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and i'm basically agnostic, so i think it would be fair to say that i am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought i'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
And to be clear, by "couldn't do" I believe you mean they felt they couldn't because of their own spiritual beliefs. I don't think the cathedral would deny them entrance..... (not picking on what you said at all, just trying to clarify this lest anyone think that the cathedral would be denying them entrance)The only thing they couldn’t do was go to the pilgrim mass in Santiago cathedral, but that was fine with all of us in our now extended camino family, and we all respected that. Buen camino! Jill
Just wondering ...... why couldn't your Muslim friends go to the pilgrim mass in Santiago cathedral. I thought everyone was welcome to attend mass. I thought it is receiving communion that is / might be an issue. Or did your friends, because of their faith, choose not to go to the pilgrim mass, or was it simply the dictates of the Muslim faith that prevented them from attending mass? Whatever their reason, I respect that. Not trying to start an issue here .... am just curious.Hello Mahmud, I started my first camino in Lisbon with my husband, and another couple, who were Muslim. My husband had to bail out with a bad leg after 10 days and return home, but my friends and I stayed together all the way to Santiago. As far as I know they had no problems, in fact they seemed to be having a really great time! and were accepted by everybody we met. The only thing they couldn’t do was go to the pilgrim mass in Santiago cathedral, but that was fine with all of us in our now extended camino family, and we all respected that. Buen camino! Jill
Correct, because of their own beliefs they didn't feel it was right for them to attend Mass.And to be clear, by "couldn't do" I believe you mean they felt they couldn't because of their own spiritual beliefs. I don't think the cathedral would deny them entrance..... (not picking on what you said at all, just trying to clarify this lest anyone think that the cathedral would be denying them entrance)
Hi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the Camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and I'm basically agnostic, so I think it would be fair to say that I am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the Camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
Hey everybody, thanks so much for your welcoming replies! You've put my (admittedly small) fears completely to rest. I don't really talk about religion that much but having an obviously Arab/Muslim name just made me a bit curious to see the responses i might get. I'll be lurking on here trying to figure out more practical stuff-backpack weight? hiking boots? yes, i know all these questions have been answered : ) - and hopefully look forward to speaking more with you all and starting my camino! Thanks again!!!
In many ways, the Camino allows the best parts of humanity to shine through, Buen Camino!
Krista
Hi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the Camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and I'm basically agnostic, so I think it would be fair to say that I am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the Camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
Hello Mahmud, I started my first camino in Lisbon with my husband, and another couple, who were Muslim. My husband had to bail out with a bad leg after 10 days and return home, but my friends and I stayed together all the way to Santiago. As far as I know they had no problems, in fact they seemed to be having a really great time! and were accepted by everybody we met. The only thing they couldn’t do was go to the pilgrim mass in Santiago cathedral, but that was fine with all of us in our now extended camino family, and we all respected that. Buen camino! Jill
I walked 3 Camino's last year.Met lots of lovely people......I have no idea what religion they were...they had no idea about mine. There are enough problems in the world with religion....one of the beautiful things about the Camino is meeting new people and not judging them.Hi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the Camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and I'm basically agnostic, so I think it would be fair to say that I am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the Camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
I have watched this thread for a day and finally someone said "jokingly" so hurrah for you Anemone. I'd like to lighten this up with something like: there must be a joke out there about a Muslim, a Jew and a Catholic meeting on the Camino and....I met a Zoroastrian on my 2nd leg. Also attended the presentation of a documentary a few years ago: a Catholic, a Jew and a Muslim walking together from Israel to Santiago. They stopped in schools, but also in refugee camps on their way, talking about their message of piece and of how we can all get along. One of the them was an osteopath, I jokingly say that I think that is why they made it to the end together, but in all seriousness their project sent out a lovely and important message.
I don't think, and I have been told this by our parish priest, the Catholic church invites all to worship at their parishes , the only restriction is receiving communion. Please enjoy every expierence on the Camino de Santiago.
Not to invoke any one doctrine but Pope Francis touched this divorced in love Catholic when he said God isn't a Catholic God.
Walk, enjoy and marvel at its grandeur.
Welcome Mahmud. I think the overwhelming response here says it all. Makes me reflect on how the world would be if all youths of all faiths and none faiths were exposed to such an environment.
Hi Mahmud I have walked different parts of the Camino and have never had a bad experience. On the Camino we leave all our excess baggage at home including our cultural and creature comforts. It is you, your legs and your backpack. You will encounter fellowship that is multicultural, multi faith and people of no faith but we all share the journey and the experiences together. I do hope that you walk the camino as I think it will give you an insight as to the kindness of your fellow brothers and sisters.Hi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the Camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and I'm basically agnostic, so I think it would be fair to say that I am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the Camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
Hi Mahmud I have walked different parts of the Camino and have never had a bad experience. On the Camino we leave all our excess baggage at home including our cultural and creature comforts. It is you, your legs and your backpack. You will encounter fellowship that is multicultural, multi faith and people of no faith but we all share the journey and the experiences together. I do hope that you walk the camino as I think it will give you an insight as to the kindness of your fellow brothers and sisters.
Buen camino Dermot
Yes, it seems strange (but amazing!) how many of you have said that you did not know/ask the religion of those you met on the camino. I suppose this shows that there is a difference between religion and spirituality and perhaps the kinds of people-from all backgrounds and walks of life it seems-that the camino attracts! I can say that after reading all of the responses I am looking forward to it now more than ever and joining this wonderful community. Now i've just got to pick a side on what seems to be endless sleeping bag vs silk liner debate!
iHi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the Camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and I'm basically agnostic, so I think it would be fair to say that I am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the Camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
So here's what I think. I would love to meet and walk on the Camino with you (or another Moslem!). I don't think anyone has a right to object or make it uncomfortable for anyone else to go on Camino. I don't think Camino can be claimed by any religion. Humans walked these paths before St James (maybe) walked them. I don't think anyone has a complete understanding of Christianity or Islam or any other belief. Camino is made by walking. Europe was made on the road to Compostela. The world needs to understand Europe. Be wary of anyone who tells you the stories of the Camino. You be the one to dig deeper. Perhaps the Knights Templar were killed because they spoke Arabic and had learnt Arab magic. Perhaps they travelled to America with Robert the Bruce's friend Sinclair and that is why the Bruce's heart was buried in Santiago (temporarily). If an atheist Pict (like me) can go on Camino then so can you. Here's a heart that's been there to bid you Buen Camino. I would love to hear your experiences when you return.Hi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the Camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and I'm basically agnostic, so I think it would be fair to say that I am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the Camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
So here's what I think. I would love to meet and walk on the Camino with you (or another Moslem!). I don't think anyone has a right to object or make it uncomfortable for anyone else to go on Camino. I don't think Camino can be claimed by any religion. Humans walked these paths before St James (maybe) walked them. I don't think anyone has a complete understanding of Christianity or Islam or any other belief. Camino is made by walking. Europe was made on the road to Compostela. The world needs to understand Europe. Be wary of anyone who tells you the stories of the Camino. You be the one to dig deeper. Perhaps the Knights Templar were killed because they spoke Arabic and had learnt Arab magic. Perhaps they travelled to America with Robert the Bruce's friend Sinclair and that is why the Bruce's heart was buried in Santiago (temporarily). If an atheist Pict (like me) can go on Camino then so can you. Here's a heart that's been there to bid you Buen Camino. I would love to hear your experiences when you return.
If there is a God then there can only be One God, therefore all religions pray to the same entity - where the problem?
Welcome to the forum I would walk with you in a heartbeat.Hi all, my name is Mahmud and I am thinking/planning on walking the Camino in late spring/early summer. Just wanted to know if people might have a problem with someone of an Arab/Muslim background taking part in a Christian pilgrimage? I'm from the UK (my dad is Egyptian/mum Turkish) and I'm basically agnostic, so I think it would be fair to say that I am doing this for spiritual reasons, but not necessarily religious ones (if that makes sense!). Oh, and has anybody ever met another Muslim (or someone from a non-Christian background, Hindu, Buddhist etc) walking the Camino and what did they think of that? Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there and see what comes back : )
On a completely unrelated note, i think these forums are really great . Everyone on here seems really helpful and nice.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?