Advice please - Gaiters April/May

M

merrellj

Member

• Feb 20, 2012

• #1

:?: Must have, ought to have, nice to have, completely unnecessary, silly question!!!

Just wondering whether I need to pack them or save the weight.

 

D

Deleted member 3000

Guest

• Feb 20, 2012

• #2

I love my gaiters, but they are not really necessary. When you wear them, the weight is borne by your shoe, so I do not count them in pack weight.

 

crhutch

Active Member

Time of past OR future Camino

(2010) March/April SJPP to Santiago and hence to Finisterre
(2016) Hospitalero Grañón 15-31 March
(2016) April Logroño to Santiago
(2017) Hospitalero Zamora 15-31 March
(2017) Hospilatero Emaus, Burgos 1-14 April

• Feb 20, 2012

• #3

I found them useful, when it rained or drizzled my upper body would be dry since I was wearing my rain jacket or my Altus rain poncho, but my pant legs would get soaked. The gaiters kept me toasty dry!

 

dougfitz

Veteran Member

Donating Member

Time of past OR future Camino

Past: a few
Last: Sanabres
Next: St Olav's Way

• Feb 21, 2012

• #4

falcon269 said:

I love my gaiters, but they are not really necessary. When you wear them, the weight is borne by your shoe, so I do not count them in pack weight.

Click to expand...

Falcon, a mere sophistry! I can almost sense the grin from here. While pack weight is important, there is also a 'from the skin out' target that experienced walkers use. 30% of bodyweight FSO is considered the maximum for comfortable hiking, with 20-25% recommended. The FSO 20% of bodyweight target appears to be slightly more generous than the 15% pack weight recommended by the CSJ, but well under a kg difference unless one is quite large. But it does mean what you wear and carry outside the pack is important in your weight budget as well.

On the subject of gaiters themselves, I wore mine regularly as an extra outer layer rather than getting out my rain pants. I can only think of two or three stretches where they were used to protect my clothing from mud or stop water dripping down into my boots from wet trousers. I am told that when I walked in 2010, it was remarkably fine. A friend who had walked at much the same time two years earlier claims he needed gaiters or rain pants most of the way from Pamplona.

Regards,

 

colinPeter

Veteran Member

Time of past OR future Camino

SJPP-SDC (2009) Somport-Jaca, Burgos-SDC, Cee-Muxia (2012) Le Puy - Aumont-Aubrac (2014) SJPP-SDC (Oct 2015)

• Feb 21, 2012

• #5

I'd be very interested to hear of any recommendations on good lightweight gaiters?
Regards
Col

 

D

Deleted member 3000

Guest

• Feb 21, 2012

• #6

The weight of gaiters is determined mostly by size. I have used both the ankle and calf length. Since I use them as umbrellas for my footwear, the shorter (and lighter) gaiters are my preference. The strap that goes under the boot can be cord, leather, or nylon. I found the leather easiest to adjust (cord is the lightest). REI has a good choice in gaiters. http://www.rei.com

 

A

annelise

Active Member

Donating Member

Time of past OR future Camino

Past

• Feb 21, 2012

• #7

May 2011, I took gaiters (advice from the forum) – rather pricey but weighty too – however, left them soon in an albergue box. Hope that someone else may have taken advantage of them!

The one day, I would have been able to take advantage of them was through a thunder and rain storm over 17 km. But even there, they would in no way have helped to keep my boots dry – walking through rivers of water on the path coming towards me or behind me depending on the slope of the trail.

I think it is better to have zip-off trouser legs (easily washed) – and then somehow try to get your boots dry for the next morning – and if not totally dry, with double socks you will be able to walk on.

 

Kialoa3

Active Member

• Feb 26, 2012

• #8

I wore gaiters every day rain or shine. They helped keep my legs warm, and my boots dry, reduced wear on inner pant legs (from boots), and kept my pants clean. I would bring them again.

 

JohnnieWalker

Nunca se camina solo

Donating Member

• Feb 26, 2012

• #9

and I never use gaiters except when walking in snow which is likely to be ankle deep

 

Abbeydore

Veteran Member

• Feb 26, 2012

• #10

falcon269 said:

The weight of gaiters is determined mostly by size. I have used both the ankle and calf length. Since I use them as umbrellas for my footwear, the shorter (and lighter) gaiters are my preference. The strap that goes under the boot can be cord, leather, or nylon. I found the leather easiest to adjust (cord is the lightest). REI has a good choice in gaiters. http://www.rei.com

Click to expand...

The cord will not last cause strangely it takes a lot of abuse, so if & when it breaks try using a bit of coat hanger bent to a U with 2 eyes @ ends

 

Rebekah Scott

Camino Busybody

Donating Member

Time of past OR future Camino

Many, various, and continuing.

• Feb 26, 2012

• #11

pilgrims have left a couple of pairs of gaiters here. I took them with me on high-altitude (snowy) caminos, but have only ever used them once or twice. They are a nice thing to have in mud, but then you have all that mud to deal with when you take them off anyway -- it´s not on your pants or boots, but it is all over your hands and the floor!

Unless you are walking in blizzards or monsoons, I can´t see any reason to carry the weight.

 

Anniesantiago

Veteran Member

Donating Member

Time of past OR future Camino

2006 to date: Over 21 Caminos. See signature line

• Feb 27, 2012

• #12

I've never worn gaiters.
Sil wears them rain or shine.
She says they also keep the rocks out of your shoes, which makes sense.
She also has a pattern for gaiters if you want to make your own.

 

M

mikevasey

Guest

• Feb 27, 2012

• #13

You could flip a coin, yes or no, you stand 50% chance of getting it right(or wrong) for the 30+ days that you are walking, thats how I feel when it comes to the the weather.
Unless I was walking the Frances in deep winter, late November to early March I would give them a miss, you will get dirty wet boots outside of that period but not hopefully too much. If you are not really sure after all the different advice, pack them, if they are lightweight you wont really notice them. I did not take any in November 2010 and did not regret it, if I had walked the same period last year, from all the blogs I read, I would have regretted it.

What is your personal feeling about it, trust your instinct. I am taking them on the Norte In May, after 85+ days over 3 caminos and in that a total of 40 minutes very soft rain and 20 minutes intense I feel I am owed some.

Good Luck

Mike

 

grayland

Veteran Member

Donating Member

Time of past OR future Camino

Yes

• Feb 27, 2012

• #14

I have not taken gaitors on my past Caminos, but on my last one I walked with a friend from Belgium who did wear them when it rained and when it was very muddy. I ended up with mud splattered pants and had to wash them each night...he did not. I am taking them next month. Hopefully, I won't see any mud because I have them with me. :wink:

 

dougfitz

Veteran Member

Donating Member

Time of past OR future Camino

Past: a few
Last: Sanabres
Next: St Olav's Way

• Feb 27, 2012

• #15

grayland said:

I am taking them next month. Hopefully, I won't see any mud because I have them with me. :wink:

Click to expand...

There are some things worth taking and not using as insurance against the inevitability that they will be needed if you don't.

 

mmm042

Active Member

Time of past OR future Camino

VDLP 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2014

• Feb 27, 2012

• #16

What are you wearing on your feet? That makes a difference, too. I alternated boots and running shoes, and wore (very lightweight) gaiters only with my running shoes, mainly to keep out the rocks/debris, although they do afford some water protection. I like Dirty Girl gaiters ($19). Don't be put off by the name; the patterns are largely unisex: http://www.dirtygirlgaiters.com/buy-it.html.

Melanie