Ian Afloat
Active Member
- Time of past OR future Camino
- CF July 25th 2017 from SJPDP
For 2024 Pilgrims: €50,- donation = 1 year with no ads on the forum + 90% off any 2024 Guide. More here. (Discount code sent to you by Private Message after your donation) |
---|
Hello everyone,
In my ill fated attempt to walk the CF in 2015 I took a 2011 edition of Brierley along with the CSJ guide with me. Now that I'm planning a hopefully not ill fated attempt this summer I'm wondering if I need to replace the Brierley and if so with what. Anything new should be up to date and not overly prescriptive about stages etc. What does the hive mind think?
Cheers,
Ian
I just tried going to Gronze.com and got some sort of Apache default page gibberish. Is that the way into it?I recommend no guide at all for the CF. Just go with the flow. That said, when I do turn to a guide I use Gronze.com online.
Ultreya,
Joe
I just tried going to Gronze.com and got some sort of Apache default page gibberish. Is that the way into it?
Some people work for a living and well, no return date, no job when you return home. ha haThe best guide is none.
Don't book any return date in advance, then just accept what comes as you walk towards and until Compostela.
The best guide is none.
Don't book any return date in advance, then just accept what comes as you walk towards and until Compostela.
Rules and availability of flights - return, open or nonexistent - vary considerably depending on what part of the world you are flying from. Yes, it can be cost-prohibitive.No return date? I've actually thought about that. But wouldn't it be cost-prohibitive when you DO get around to booking a flight/train?
I think it's great to have information about albergues that are open, especially if you travel outside the May-October season or if you travel in the absolute height of the season.Hello everyone,
In my ill fated attempt to walk the CF in 2015 I took a 2011 edition of Brierley along with the CSJ guide with me. Now that I'm planning a hopefully not ill fated attempt this summer I'm wondering if I need to replace the Brierley and if so with what. Anything new should be up to date and not overly prescriptive about stages etc. What does the hive mind think?
Cheers,
Ian
I'm with Robert on the advantages of having some info with you about what you are seeing. Though I DID read up beforehand, my mind didn't retain much. Brierly was the one I used at the time, and I liked his elevation diagrams, the spiritual commentary for each stage, and the size of the guide. Another family member is walking CF in one week, she's younger, and picked out the Dinatmin guide, which has more pictures, not a spiritual focus, but a large amount of contact info and availability of cafes, albergues, etc. for various places, all in a coded format. My younger family member prefers this guide. So maybe go to a bookstore that might have both if you can, and compare. Both have very good infomation, just presented slightly differently. One book is tall/narrow, one is more square. You can probably also get an idea from looking at a sample on Amazon.People who only carried the Brierley will tell you it's the only way to go. People who only carried Village to Village will tell you it's the only the to go. People who only carried the German guide book will tell you it's the only way to go. I carried all three on my last Camino. If I was only going to carry one, it would be Village to Village by Dintamin.
People who never carried a guidebook will tell you not carrying one is the only way to go. I personally cannot image not being able to read about the rich history of the monuments, bridges, and churches I pass each hour. To be able to stop and learn about an extremely important historical sight as I was literally standing in front of it was an important part of my experience. Also, I liked to have a general idea of the remaining route and it's infrastructure each day.
I just tried going to Gronze.com and got some sort of Apache default page gibberish. Is that the way into it?
I'm not sure how advantageous this is but the Wikipedia article at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visa_policy_of_the_Schengen_Area says:I believe it's illegal to enter Shegan Agreement area without a return plane ticket that has a return date less than 180 days from your arrival. In theory, you could be denied entry. The easier method is to book a return ticket that is 60 or 90 days out and adjust it as you come to the end of your Camino. If you buy your ticket directly from an airline such as Delta, it's usually free to change the return date. At most, you'll pay $150.
I would get Brierley CF Maps only Guide. Buen CaminoHello everyone,
In my ill fated attempt to walk the CF in 2015 I took a 2011 edition of Brierley along with the CSJ guide with me. Now that I'm planning a hopefully not ill fated attempt this summer I'm wondering if I need to replace the Brierley and if so with what. Anything new should be up to date and not overly prescriptive about stages etc. What does the hive mind think?
Cheers,
Ian
The Confraternity of St James in London has a 2107 fully updated ( by pilgrim walkers in 2016) CF guidebook for £7 , light to carry, no stages suggested, full accommodation list...Robin DorkingsHello everyone,
In my ill fated attempt to walk the CF in 2015 I took a 2011 edition of Brierley along with the CSJ guide with me. Now that I'm planning a hopefully not ill fated attempt this summer I'm wondering if I need to replace the Brierley and if so with what. Anything new should be up to date and not overly prescriptive about stages etc. What does the hive mind think?
Cheers,
Ian
ditch Brierley, if you need alternative routes, roads or what is more to the point, exact maps and distances, you will need more than Brierley. He takes a stab at it and has been lacking, seriously. Pellegrinos have used mobile aps. that have perfect maps and info. It shall be my choice if I go again.Hello everyone,
In my ill fated attempt to walk the CF in 2015 I took a 2011 edition of Brierley along with the CSJ guide with me. Now that I'm planning a hopefully not ill fated attempt this summer I'm wondering if I need to replace the Brierley and if so with what. Anything new should be up to date and not overly prescriptive about stages etc. What does the hive mind think?
Cheers,
Ian
Hi IanHello everyone,
In my ill fated attempt to walk the CF in 2015 I took a 2011 edition of Brierley along with the CSJ guide with me. Now that I'm planning a hopefully not ill fated attempt this summer I'm wondering if I need to replace the Brierley and if so with what. Anything new should be up to date and not overly prescriptive about stages etc. What does the hive mind think?
Cheers,
Ian
Hi Ian
I plan to walk my first Camino in May/June this year and guide books (like yes or no to walking poles) seem to be one of those never ending hot topics. Like you, I'll only be taking a summarised map version on the trail. I've purchased two types to compare. Predictably one is the Brierley and the other is the Michelin SJPD to Santiago, product code 160. It also has a companion guide Le Puy to SJPD (161). It's lighter (every gram counts) than the Brierly and provides a helpful topographical elevation view of every day's walk. One day to a page with walking map on the adjacent page. It lacks the extra city plans and detailed albergue lists but is very easy to follow. Considering the volume of people and easy directions on the trail I think it may be the guide for me. Hope this helps.
Happy trails
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?