Melinda Francis
New Member
- Time of past OR future Camino
- Plan to walk within the next year (Jun2016-Jun2017)
For 2024 Pilgrims: €50,- donation = 1 year with no ads on the forum + 90% off any 2024 Guide. More here. (Discount code sent to you by Private Message after your donation) |
---|
Is it two weeks to start the Camino or decide on the boots and start training. These boots needs some breaking before the Camino. Hope it is the latter.Hi All!
My first post on the forum!
I am having shoe dilemmas. I've tried many pairs and narrowed it down to 2 pairs - ASOLO Revert GT and Scarpa Terra's. I actually bought the ASOS but am still unsure and have 2 weeks to decide!
The ASOLO are a stiffer boot with a lot more stability (this is a plus for me as I have bad knees and ankles) and are goretex, however the Terra's are leather with goretex lining and are all cushiony and nice inside but the support is not as great. They weigh the same at 1200gm a pair. I'm sure the stiffer boot needs time to wear in but do I go for stability or cushioning?
Also - they measured my feet as a 41. I have plenty of toe wiggle room and as I have a narrow foot room on the edges. Is this enough or do I need to go up another size? I practiced walking the ramps and my toes don't hit the front of the boots when going downhill..
Thanks again! Melinda
It is generally a good idea to get a 1/2 size bigger for long distance walking, to allow for varying sock thickness and to have some wiggle room. Since you have a narrow feet don't need to size up too much. But, the shoe must fit snugly. If not, try shows that are made for narrow feet. Again, Lowa makes narrow widths.Hi All!
Also - they measured my feet as a 41. I have plenty of toe wiggle room and as I have a narrow foot room on the edges. Is this enough or do I need to go up another size? I practiced walking the ramps and my toes don't hit the front of the boots when going downhill..
Thanks again! Melinda
Is it two weeks to start the Camino or decide on the boots and start training. These boots needs some breaking before the Camino. Hope it is the latter.
Looking at the specs, the Scarpa uses PU (polyurethane) midsole and the Asolo uses EVA. Your instinct is right, the reason Scarpa feels nice and confy is because it is probably using high quality PU midsole along with some softer synthetic interior. When it comes to quality cushioning PU is the king.
EVA is made popular by runners. They have great cushioning but lacks durability. So, technically Scarpa should be better in this respect.
The outer layer, leather vs synthetic is less important as both use gtx layer. May be Asolo with a slight edge.
Do you sweat a lot? If so, avoid any gtx layers at any cost in a boot. Leather breathes better and can provide sufficient water proofing. If you are considering this class of boots, have you tried the Lowa renegades? I used them on two Caminos. They come in leather lined version. Breathes better. And a good all around boot for the Camino which is hardly a technical trail. For knee issues I would use trekking poles.
Strictly speaking lighter weight shoes would be better. Then you need to consider ankle braces to gain some support. Since I don't face angle issues per se I cannot offer any concrete suggestion. I have seen lot of hikers with active ankle braces and trail shoes.Thank you Rajy.
I have 2 weeks to try out the boots - at least 3 months till Camino!
I don't sweat a lot but will wear moisture wicking liners and air my feet regularly. Also thinking of taking a pair of sandals as an alternative.....
I'm now concerned the weight of the boot is too much at 540gm each. Should I go for something lighter?
I don't think I can get Lowa in Australia. I haven't seen them anywhere.
Thanks again
The two boots you have listed are going to be very competent four-season bush-walking boots in Australia. If these were recommended by an outdoor retailer, I suggest you make it clear what you are going to use them for, or find another retailer. There are Camino savvy outdoors retailers in many Australian capital cities but there may not be much experience in most regional centres.I'm now concerned the weight of the boot is too much at 540gm each. Should I go for something lighter?
ksThe two boots you have listed are going to be very competent four-season bush-walking boots in Australia. If these were recommended by an outdoor retailer, I suggest you make it clear what you are going to use them for, or find another retailer. There are Camino savvy outdoors retailers in many Australian capital cities but there may not be much experience in most regional centres.
Unless you have specific issues with ankle stability, both these boots will 'over match' the conditions you will meet on the vast majority of the CF. A mid-height boot with a low cut back should suffice, as should a good walking shoe.
@Rajy62, Lowa are not retailed in Australia. Under the circumstances, I am not sure I would be recommending an online purchase.
Strictly speaking lighter weight shoes would be better. Then you need to consider ankle braces to gain some support. Since I don't face angle issues per se I cannot offer any concrete suggestion. I have seen lot of hikers with active ankle braces and trail shoes.
If you have weak ankles would sandals provide enough support?
Google shows this site selling Lowa in Australia. You may have to order online try/return. Three months is enough to find a suitable shoes.
If you plan to walk the Camino frances, approximately 50% of your walk will be on paved roads, some on gravel and some on rocky uneven trails but well developed. So you can get away with lightweight boot/shoes with some ankle braces. Good luck.
Melinda,Yes I think I will look at hiking shoes instead. My ankles shouldn't be too bad if I take care of my knees. Hopefully hiking poles will help with that!
Im only looking at taking the sandals as a backup in case my feet need airing
LolI saw a guy in Flip-Flops today
I also use a Salomon boot that fits my entire foot like a glove, holding it in position but leaving good wiggle room in the toe box. I haven't found another brand that fits my foot so well.I ended up returning the Asolos. They seemed like overkill and were heavy. I tried just shoes but found my toes slipped to the front of the shoe when going downhill because there was nothing to hold my ankle back - I'm hoping to keep my toenails so went with a mid boot - the salomon x ultra mid - they're lightweight and instantly comfy - I didn't have to talk myself into them! I also replaced the inner soles with Green Superfeet for arch and heel support. Thank you all for your help- hitting the home trails and hoping for the best!
Thanks Kanga. I am going to take sandals too and rotate. Which did you use?Dear @Melinda Francis - I've just returned from walking the Camino Frances (again) entirely in sandals. That is not for everyone but as a general rule, all other things being equal, the lighter the shoe the better. It may be hot in July, possibly very hot.
Hi Melinda. I've been doing a bit of long distance walking over the years and I've found that Teva sandals are a really good alternative. I found the problem with wearing ankle top boots was that over time my ankles got lazy and weaker as a result. Since walking in Keens and Tevas I've never had a problem. Nice cool feet too.Hi All!
My first post on the forum!
I am having shoe dilemmas. I've tried many pairs and narrowed it down to 2 pairs - ASOLO Revert GT and Scarpa Terra's. I actually bought the ASOS but am still unsure and have 2 weeks to decide!
The ASOLO are a stiffer boot with a lot more stability (this is a plus for me as I have bad knees and ankles) and are goretex, however the Terra's are leather with goretex lining and are all cushiony and nice inside but the support is not as great. They weigh the same at 1200gm a pair. I'm sure the stiffer boot needs time to wear in but do I go for stability or cushioning?
Also - they measured my feet as a 41. I have plenty of toe wiggle room and as I have a narrow foot room on the edges. Is this enough or do I need to go up another size? I practiced walking the ramps and my toes don't hit the front of the boots when going downhill..
Thanks again! Melinda
Boots are a very personal thing, what suits some, doesn't suit someone else, but I walked in the Scarpa Terra's on the Camino. They were so comfortable, I didn't know I had them on and no blister Buen Camino.Hi All!
My first post on the forum!
I am having shoe dilemmas. I've tried many pairs and narrowed it down to 2 pairs - ASOLO Revert GT and Scarpa Terra's. I actually bought the ASOS but am still unsure and have 2 weeks to decide!
The ASOLO are a stiffer boot with a lot more stability (this is a plus for me as I have bad knees and ankles) and are goretex, however the Terra's are leather with goretex lining and are all cushiony and nice inside but the support is not as great. They weigh the same at 1200gm a pair. I'm sure the stiffer boot needs time to wear in but do I go for stability or cushioning?
Also - they measured my feet as a 41. I have plenty of toe wiggle room and as I have a narrow foot room on the edges. Is this enough or do I need to go up another size? I practiced walking the ramps and my toes don't hit the front of the boots when going downhill..
Thanks again! Melinda
Hi Melinda. I wore Scarpa Terra's. They were extremely comfortable and light. The bonus no blisters.Hi All!
My first post on the forum!
I am having shoe dilemmas. I've tried many pairs and narrowed it down to 2 pairs - ASOLO Revert GT and Scarpa Terra's. I actually bought the ASOS but am still unsure and have 2 weeks to decide!
The ASOLO are a stiffer boot with a lot more stability (this is a plus for me as I have bad knees and ankles) and are goretex, however the Terra's are leather with goretex lining and are all cushiony and nice inside but the support is not as great. They weigh the same at 1200gm a pair. I'm sure the stiffer boot needs time to wear in but do I go for stability or cushioning?
Also - they measured my feet as a 41. I have plenty of toe wiggle room and as I have a narrow foot room on the edges. Is this enough or do I need to go up another size? I practiced walking the ramps and my toes don't hit the front of the boots when going downhill..
Thanks again! Melinda
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?