17 Sept-29 Oct CF What jacket to bring?

[Walking Julie]

Hi all,
Newbie here...
I'm having a jacket dilemma. So far for cloathes, I'm bringing 2 short sleeve and 1 long sleeve merino wool tops. Also a long sleeve fleece. (Convertible pants and leggings). So this is the question, from the list below,what would you decide to bring for outer "jacket" layer? I'm planning to bring a poncho to cover both me and my pack. I'm thinking it's going to be pretty cold the end of October in Finisterre. (I'll be starting in SJPdP) Need someone with a little more experience to shed some light.

This is what I have to choose from:

Down jacket with hood (ultra light)
Down vest (ultra light)
Wind breaker with hood (light)
Columbia rain jacket (heaviest but doable option)

My thought was down jacket for warmth with windbreaker.

Thanks in advance for all your input!

Julie

 

[norelle]

Hi Julie

I'm planning my 4th camino - similar dates to you.

I'm going to bring my standard light long-sleeve merino, plus a warmer merino jacket and a light water-proof/wind jacket that I've taken on all my spring/summer caminos.

But I'll be adding to that an ultra light weight down jacket. I met a pilgrim last year who had one (and I was a bit envious) and he wore it many times - in June! So I'm thinking I may need one in October, especially towards the end of the month.

happy planning

buen camino

Norelle

 

[whariwharangi]

Rain jacket will be needed even with a poncho.

Rain jacket will cut wind too.

Down Jacket. You won't want it during the day, particularly with the wool shirts on, but you will want it in the evenings.

You will radiate a lot of heat through walking with a pack and won't want much for outer layers.

Bring a scarf, light ragknit wool gloves, and a fleece hat.

Long sleeve is better than short ... you can roll the sleeves if needs be. Bring nylon or cotton shirts ... leave the merino at home. Yeah it holds off washing for a few days but eventually you will want to and it will take f o r e v e r to dry.

 

[HikingCharlotte]

Hi all,
Newbie here...
I'm having a jacket dilemma. So far for cloathes, I'm bringing 2 short sleeve and 1 long sleeve merino wool tops. Also a long sleeve fleece. (Convertible pants and leggings). So this is the question, from the list below,what would you decide to bring for outer "jacket" layer? I'm planning to bring a poncho to cover both me and my pack. I'm thinking it's going to be pretty cold the end of October in Finisterre. (I'll be starting in SJPdP) Need someone with a little more experience to shed some light.

This is what I have to choose from:

Down jacket with hood (ultra light)
Down vest (ultra light)
Wind breaker with hood (light)
Columbia rain jacket (heaviest but doable option)

My thought was down jacket for warmth with windbreaker.

Thanks in advance for all your input!

Julie

Hi Julie,
Im setting off on 18/9 so look out fir me. Had anticipated leaving down jacket behind but these comments suggest otherwise..evenings seem to be the main problem

 

[Bradypus]

A lot depends on the temperatures you are used to at home. I lay on an hostel bunk in Porto very comfortably in shorts and t-shirt while a young Korean woman sitting on the next bunk shivered in front of a fan heater while wearing three layers of wool sweaters and a heavy wool overcoat! Personally I would leave the down jacket at home and take a light rain jacket - adding or removing layers of fleece/shirt/T-shirt underneath for comfort. Although a down jacket can be quite light I find one is overkill and not worth the additional bulk along the Camino routes except in midwinter and in the mountain sections.

 

[t2andreo]

I recommend a hooded rain parka shell, in a bright color for visibility when road walking. Buy the parka shell one size larger than you might otherwise to allow for layering your fleece and additional items underneath, if the weather turns cold abruptly.

Also, do try to find a rain shell parka with "pit zips." this allows you to open both armpits to promote ventilation as you walk.

I hope this helps.

 

[Walking Julie]

Thank you!

 

[backpack45]

Down jacket and rain jacket for me are insurance. You don't know if you will need it, but when you do... I think one merino wool, and one or two synthetic shirts. (Veteran of 14 Caminos--with rain, hail, snow, as well as 100 temps)..

 

[LouiseEdin]

I don't go anywhere without my micro down ran jacket

 

[Quasi]

Hi all,
I am also a newbie, doing my first Camino from Sept 25th to Nov 2nd. I have been tossing up whether to bring a soft shell windbreaker or not. Now I think I will I am taking 1 long sleeve and 2 short sleeve tops all marino. I was also taking my waterproof lightweight jacket. What are the temperatures at night? I was also tossing up whether to take a lightweight sleeping bag, should I?
Would love all your advise.
Cheers.

 

[AlwynWellington]

leave the merino at home .... it will take f o r e v e r to dry

My experience with washing merino tops is that they are amongst the first to dry.

 

[Quasi]

Well I have decided to take my merino tops and hope the weather isnt too wet.
Cheers
Buen camino

 

[Hiawatha]

I find that Super fine Merino wool T shirts and tops dry faster than polypropylene . The added advantage is that they don't smell like dead Wombat after a day of sweat and dirt .

 

[gerardcarey]

You'll need 4 layers to cover all eventualities.
So the need is to cover the worst eventuality, cold and rain.
You could utilise a short sleeve merino over which would go the long sleeve merino, topped by the fleece.
But your query is to the outer layer.
The requirement now is not for warmth. It is for rain protection.
May I suggest your choice is therefore between a shell jacket or a poncho.
Then a decision is required as to whether and how to protect your legs.
Remember that socks make great wicks and enable, probably guarantee, the transfer of moisture into the interior of your footwear.
Regards
Gerard

 

[Quasi]

Thanks for the advise. I am taking my wet weather gear, both pants and jacket. It is hard to know what to leave behind and what to take when you have to be mindful about weight. My pack at the moment is 8.3 kgs.

 

[Walking Julie]

You'll need 4 layers to cover all eventualities.
So the need is to cover the worst eventuality, cold and rain.
You could utilise a short sleeve merino over which would go the long sleeve merino, topped by the fleece.
But your query is to the outer layer.
The requirement now is not for warmth. It is for rain protection.
May I suggest your choice is therefore between a shell jacket or a poncho.
Then a decision is required as to whether and how to protect your legs.
Remember that socks make great wicks and enable, probably guarantee, the transfer of moisture into the interior of your footwear.
Regards
Gerard

My pack is at 5.5 k without water. I think I'm going to spray my convertible pants with a water repellant. I have wet weather jacket and poncho. Still debating down jacket or down vest. I will be bringing a light weight fleece. Wondering if down jacket is overkill and should only bring vest....thoughts?

 

[Dancing Rain]

I'd choose windproof very light weight jacket with hood (not on list) and down vest.

 

[Walking Julie]

I'd choose windproof very light weight jacket with hood (not on list) and down vest.

Thanks for the input!!! Why, I do have a light weight windproof/windbreaker jacket with hood, on my list to choose from. That was my initial though to use, with down jacket. Then I thought perhaps my Columbia waterproof jacket with down vest and light fleece was perhaps a better combo. Of course in the end, it's just an educated guess because I have no idea what the weather will throw at me....

 

[Deleted member 3000]

Wondering if down jacket is overkill and should only bring vest....thoughts?

I have a closet full of vests that are great in fall/winter. I would never bring one on a Camino. It is single use piece of equipment. Instead, layer. T-shirt, short sleeve shirt, long sleeve shirt, windbreaker, and poncho (Altus or Packa). Each is perfect for some weather, and layered, they will conquer all weather conditions (including a blizzard). Style just does not count on the Camino.

 

[gerardcarey]

I have a closet full of vests that are great in fall/winter. I would never bring one on a Camino. It is single use piece of equipment. Instead, layer. T-shirt, short sleeve shirt, long sleeve shirt, windbreaker, and poncho (Altus or Packa). Each is perfect for some weather, and layered, they will conquer all weather conditions (including a blizzard). Style just does not count on the Camino.

Those of us coming from some distance, and for time spent in Europe before and after our Camino, need something somewhat dressier than a windbreaker for attending functions, going out for dinner, shows, movies, family functions etc.
That is why I utilise a soft shell fleece, one that is more dressy, and slightly more expensive. Not just one of the fluffy ones that would quite suffice for Camino use.
Multipurpose! We've learnt how important that is.
Regards
Gerard

 

[Dancing Rain]

Thanks for the input!!! Why, I do have a light weight windproof/windbreaker jacket with hood, on my list to choose from. That was my initial though to use, with down jacket. Then I thought perhaps my Columbia waterproof jacket with down vest and light fleece was perhaps a better combo. Of course in the end, it's just an educated guess because I have no idea what the weather will throw at me....

The difference I was emphasising was extra/ultra lightweight jacket - no frills. About the vest - I used my vest a lot and felt no need for a down jacket because I had my light weight fleece. I also used my merino leggings a lot - in the evenings and in bed. To each their own - I run cold and like to be prepared for very cold, which it was sometimes during our Sept/Oct Camino.

 

[Dancing Rain]

Hi all,
I am also a newbie, doing my first Camino from Sept 25th to Nov 2nd. I have been tossing up whether to bring a soft shell windbreaker or not. Now I think I will I am taking 1 long sleeve and 2 short sleeve tops all marino. I was also taking my waterproof lightweight jacket. What are the temperatures at night? I was also tossing up whether to take a lightweight sleeping bag, should I?
Would love all your advise.
Cheers.

Highly recommend taking a light weight sleeping bag. I couldn't imagine being without mine for comfort, privacy and warmth

 

[Walking Julie]

The difference I was emphasising was extra/ultra lightweight jacket - no frills. About the vest - I used my vest a lot and felt no need for a down jacket because I had my light weight fleece. I also used my merino leggings a lot - in the evenings and in bed. To each their own - I run cold and like to be prepared for very cold, which it was sometimes during our Sept/Oct Camino.

So, you think a vest with fleece and light weight windbreaker is a good option..? (It's all about the layers...learned that living in Seattle for 10 years LOL). I'm bringing a stuff able down blanket I bought at Costco $19.99. Can't beat that.
Thanks!

 

[Dancing Rain]

So, you think a vest with fleece and light weight windbreaker is a good option..? (It's all about the layers...learned that living in Seattle for 10 years LOL). I'm bringing a stuff able down blanket I bought at Costco $19.99. Can't beat that.
Thanks!

I think a vest with light weight fleece & windbreaker are a great option. As you say its all about the layers.

 

[Walking Julie]

I think a vest with light weight fleece & windbreaker are a great option. As you say its all about the layers.

Thank you

 

[Quasi]

After reading all these posts, I think I am happy taking short sleeve marino tops, a long sleeve marino top, a hooded windbreaker and a wet weather jacket, and I will take my sleeping bag. Hopefully I will be warm enough.
Thankyou for your input.

 

[Dancing Rain]

After reading all these posts, I think I am happy taking short sleeve marino tops, a long sleeve marino top, a hooded windbreaker and a wet weather jacket, and I will take my sleeping bag. Hopefully I will be warm enough.
Thankyou for your input.

Have a fabulous time. Buen camino!!!!